+ Reply to Thread
Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 39

Thread: Republican Anarchism and the Coming Revolution

  1. #1
    Top Poster

    Cael Dubh has a reputation beyond repute Cael Dubh has a reputation beyond repute Cael Dubh has a reputation beyond repute Cael Dubh has a reputation beyond repute Cael Dubh has a reputation beyond repute Cael Dubh has a reputation beyond repute Cael Dubh has a reputation beyond repute Cael Dubh has a reputation beyond repute Cael Dubh has a reputation beyond repute Cael Dubh has a reputation beyond repute Cael Dubh has a reputation beyond repute Cael Dubh's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2007
    Location
    Aontas Sóvéideach na hÉireann
    Posts
    16,257
    Thanks
    642
    Thanked 1,714 Times in 795 Posts

    Republican Anarchism and the Coming Revolution

    Republican Anarchism and the Coming Revolution

    A chairde, agus a Phoblachtanaigh, I wish to suggest some possible developments on the excellent Éire Nua and Saol Nua documents. As these proposals are set out now, they are a blue print for a future Irish Republic. They assume that the Republic will have been re-established when they are put into effect. To my mind, this is to ignore the full potential of these documents. The Community Councils they propose could and, to my mind, should be the engines of Revolution today, and in the very teeth of the enemy. For this to become a reality, the size of the Community Council needs to be greatly reduced to a maximum of 200 citizens. Community Councils could be set up right now with as little as five to ten citizens, providing goods and services that the community needs and providing employment. Funding would be provided by the Army, after an extensive campaign of capital recovery from the 1% of the Irish population who have expropriated 50% of Ireland’s capital. (Most Republicans still have very little idea of the colossal scale of the wealth of these individuals. In 2006 Irish citizens held 2.3 trillion euro in foreign property and stocks, I know it is less now, but it still amounts to almost unimaginable wealth. Getting a billion euro of this, the Republic’s rightful property, would be far less risky than the noble deeds the Volunteers carried out last weekend, and would be equally noble in its conclusion.) Expropriate the expropriators, as Marx put it. These Community Councils would then become institutions of the really existing 32 County Irish Republic. Nobody could then ask where is the Republic – it would exist before their eyes in Irish working class communities building a new life for themselves and their children. We already have communities organising themselves around the drugs issue – this would be just one small step further from the excellent work they are already doing, but a step over the Rubicon of actual Revolution.


    Backround

    The great mistake of the Republican Movement in the 20th Century has been to follow DeVelera’s injunction: Labour must wait. The idea seems to be that when we have pushed out the Brits, we can, in peace, sort out the economic oppression of our people. Nothing could be further from the truth. There is far more chance of sorting out the National Struggle in peace than the Economic Struggle. If, next week, we managed to push out the Brits, Im very sorry to say that many of us who wanted to move on to the Economic Revolution would find ourselves staring down the rifles of former comrades. Don’t say it couldn’t happen – it already has, over and over again.
    No, a chairde, the Economic Revolution comes first. It is the Economic Revolution that powers and drives the National Revolution. We have been putting the cart before the ass. Michael Davitt realised this in the 19th century, but the middle class Catholic Nationalists shafted him because they wanted the spoils all for themselves.


    Direct Democracy

    This is where Anarchism comes in. I believe that Éire Nua needs to take one step forward, away from the Anglo-Saxon representational parliamentary system, and fully embrace Direct Democracy. We don’t need leaders. What we need is self empowered Community Councils, organised along the Federal basis set out in Éire Nua. In a Revolutionary situation, where the enemy is using their armies and paramilitary police forces to try and crush the Revolution, representational democracy is a non starter anyway. What we need is Community Councils that can function in themselves, even when isolated by enemy offensive. Every Community Council is a microcosm of the whole Republic. The enemy cannot destroy the Republic until it has destroyed each and every Community Council. The Community Council, as stated in Éire Nua, is the basic democratic unit of the Republic. All elements of the Republic are contained within the structure of the Community Council. Sounds fragmented? Certainly. Too fragmented for the enemy to defeat, but held together by the great ideals of the Irish Republic and the dignity of Labour, which are, in fact, one and the same ideal.

    We have to stop worrying about offending the property conscious small farmers, who have often, its true, given so much to our struggle. It should be easy enough to convince Republican minded small farmers that they are not our targets.
    And if they can’t be convinced, then so be it. We work without them.

    The Irish people may not be quite ready for this proposal right now, but the free state is falling apart, as is the British state. Even now, working class youth is in revolt, but only the drugs gangs are harnessing their energy and righteous anger – when it should be the Republican Movement.

    There is a wonderful scene in the film Doctor Zhivago, where two Revolutionaries have been ordered to join the Tsarist Army marching to meet the Germans, an older man and a young man. The young man sets out straight away to convince the troops to revolt, but the older man holds him back. He points to the boots on the soldier’s feet, and says: Wait till they have no boots.

    As I’ve said in another thread, spreading the Revolution to Britain is an essential component of success. We have to start looking on the British working class as our potential allies and comrades. They are fine people and good fighters. I tell you it made my blood boil to see old age pensioners in England, who had fought the Nazis, cutting back on cups of tea because they can’t afford the water and electricity charges the bastard privateers are inflicting on them.

    A chairde, our time has come, if we have the sense to see it. The mis-ruling class are reeling, they only need a push.
    Slavery and private land ownership are one and the same thing. The so called ending of slavery was just half of the job. The ending of private land ownership is the other half

    A person who is flabby and shaky on questions of theory — such a man is not a revolutionary, but a wretched amateur! V.I. Lenin

    Cael's Blog: http://irishsocialistrepublic.blogspot.com/

  2. #2
    Senior Member
    KillinSnakes has a reputation beyond repute KillinSnakes has a reputation beyond repute KillinSnakes has a reputation beyond repute KillinSnakes has a reputation beyond repute KillinSnakes has a reputation beyond repute KillinSnakes has a reputation beyond repute KillinSnakes has a reputation beyond repute KillinSnakes has a reputation beyond repute KillinSnakes has a reputation beyond repute KillinSnakes has a reputation beyond repute KillinSnakes has a reputation beyond repute KillinSnakes's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2007
    Location
    "apologist scum"
    Posts
    4,679
    Thanks
    665
    Thanked 274 Times in 114 Posts
    Republican Anarchism? What does this mean. It sounds like a contradiction in terms.
    Subscribe to the IRSCNA Youtube Channel http://www.youtube.com/user/IRSCNA

    "Radical theory tends to grow unpleasantly narcissistic when deprived of a political outlet." -Terry Eagleton

  3. #3
    Banned youth8of1ireland has a reputation beyond repute youth8of1ireland has a reputation beyond repute youth8of1ireland has a reputation beyond repute youth8of1ireland has a reputation beyond repute youth8of1ireland has a reputation beyond repute youth8of1ireland has a reputation beyond repute youth8of1ireland has a reputation beyond repute youth8of1ireland has a reputation beyond repute youth8of1ireland has a reputation beyond repute youth8of1ireland has a reputation beyond repute youth8of1ireland has a reputation beyond repute
    Join Date
    Nov 2008
    Location
    Dublin
    Posts
    2,160
    Thanks
    0
    Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by KillinSnakes View Post
    Republican Anarchism? What does this mean. It sounds like a contradiction in terms.
    Yes it is, Im no ideology Theologian but this is not possible as Anarchism is a Political ideology that sees the government as unnecessary and this contradicts the Commitment to the All Ireland Republic Government or the official Dail Eireann.

    How can both compliment each other when one Contradicts the Core of our Struggle?

  4. #4
    Top Poster

    Cael Dubh has a reputation beyond repute Cael Dubh has a reputation beyond repute Cael Dubh has a reputation beyond repute Cael Dubh has a reputation beyond repute Cael Dubh has a reputation beyond repute Cael Dubh has a reputation beyond repute Cael Dubh has a reputation beyond repute Cael Dubh has a reputation beyond repute Cael Dubh has a reputation beyond repute Cael Dubh has a reputation beyond repute Cael Dubh has a reputation beyond repute Cael Dubh's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2007
    Location
    Aontas Sóvéideach na hÉireann
    Posts
    16,257
    Thanks
    642
    Thanked 1,714 Times in 795 Posts
    Its only a contraction if you consider that a centralised state is the only form a Republic can have. I don't see any reason to believe this. It's true that many Anarchists do not want borders of any type, but by no means all. In the Spainish civil war some of the most patriotic fighters were Anarchists, and they certainly had no desire to see the end of Spain.

    A Republic based on Community Councils is no contradiction at all. Indeed, Cuba has already done a lot of work towards this goal. You would still need a Federal System, similar to the one outlined in Éire Nua, and Dáil Éireann would then be an assembly of delegates rather than representatives. I believe that would be a great improvement.
    Last edited by Cael Dubh; 03-19-2009 at 12:42 PM.
    Slavery and private land ownership are one and the same thing. The so called ending of slavery was just half of the job. The ending of private land ownership is the other half

    A person who is flabby and shaky on questions of theory — such a man is not a revolutionary, but a wretched amateur! V.I. Lenin

    Cael's Blog: http://irishsocialistrepublic.blogspot.com/

  5. #5
    New User 1913 is on a distinguished road
    Join Date
    Jun 2007
    Posts
    105
    Thanks
    1
    Thanked 1 Time in 1 Post
    This has been posted on the AnarchistBlackCat forums:

    http://www.anarchistblackcat.org/vie...1113&start=135

  6. #6
    Banned youth8of1ireland has a reputation beyond repute youth8of1ireland has a reputation beyond repute youth8of1ireland has a reputation beyond repute youth8of1ireland has a reputation beyond repute youth8of1ireland has a reputation beyond repute youth8of1ireland has a reputation beyond repute youth8of1ireland has a reputation beyond repute youth8of1ireland has a reputation beyond repute youth8of1ireland has a reputation beyond repute youth8of1ireland has a reputation beyond repute youth8of1ireland has a reputation beyond repute
    Join Date
    Nov 2008
    Location
    Dublin
    Posts
    2,160
    Thanks
    0
    Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by Cael View Post
    Its only a contraction if you consider that a centralised state is the only form a Republic can have. I don't see any reason to believe this. It's true that many Anarchists do not want borders of any type, but by no means all. In the Spainish civil war some of the most patriotic fighters were Anarchists, and they certainly had no desire to see the end of Spain.

    A Republic based on Community Councils is no contradiction at all. Indeed, Cuba has already done a lot of work towards this goal. You would still need a Federal System, similar to the one outlined in Éire Nua, and Dáil Éireann would then be an assembly of delegates rather than representatives. I believe that would be a great improvement.
    All you need to do is look at the opinion the WSM as Anarchists had the time of the RIR Parade.

  7. #7
    Top Poster

    Cael Dubh has a reputation beyond repute Cael Dubh has a reputation beyond repute Cael Dubh has a reputation beyond repute Cael Dubh has a reputation beyond repute Cael Dubh has a reputation beyond repute Cael Dubh has a reputation beyond repute Cael Dubh has a reputation beyond repute Cael Dubh has a reputation beyond repute Cael Dubh has a reputation beyond repute Cael Dubh has a reputation beyond repute Cael Dubh has a reputation beyond repute Cael Dubh's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2007
    Location
    Aontas Sóvéideach na hÉireann
    Posts
    16,257
    Thanks
    642
    Thanked 1,714 Times in 795 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by youth8of1ireland View Post
    All you need to do is look at the opinion the WSM as Anarchists had the time of the RIR Parade.
    Anarchism is an idea, the WSM has no power to define it. They have their own opinion, and that's that. It really doesnt matter what we call it, the main thing is a move away from the traditional Republican paradigm of centralised leadership that has served Republicanism so disasterously over the last 100 years, and a move towards Community Councils (Which is in Éire Nua anyway.) Community Councils can be set up today, we don't have to wait until the final defeat of British imperialism.
    Slavery and private land ownership are one and the same thing. The so called ending of slavery was just half of the job. The ending of private land ownership is the other half

    A person who is flabby and shaky on questions of theory — such a man is not a revolutionary, but a wretched amateur! V.I. Lenin

    Cael's Blog: http://irishsocialistrepublic.blogspot.com/

  8. #8
    Top Poster

    Cael Dubh has a reputation beyond repute Cael Dubh has a reputation beyond repute Cael Dubh has a reputation beyond repute Cael Dubh has a reputation beyond repute Cael Dubh has a reputation beyond repute Cael Dubh has a reputation beyond repute Cael Dubh has a reputation beyond repute Cael Dubh has a reputation beyond repute Cael Dubh has a reputation beyond repute Cael Dubh has a reputation beyond repute Cael Dubh has a reputation beyond repute Cael Dubh's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2007
    Location
    Aontas Sóvéideach na hÉireann
    Posts
    16,257
    Thanks
    642
    Thanked 1,714 Times in 795 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by 1913 View Post
    This has been posted on the AnarchistBlackCat forums:

    http://www.anarchistblackcat.org/vie...1113&start=135

    Very few people people post on the Irish section of that site. They express their own personal opinions and nothing more.
    Slavery and private land ownership are one and the same thing. The so called ending of slavery was just half of the job. The ending of private land ownership is the other half

    A person who is flabby and shaky on questions of theory — such a man is not a revolutionary, but a wretched amateur! V.I. Lenin

    Cael's Blog: http://irishsocialistrepublic.blogspot.com/

  9. #9
    Senior Member
    KillinSnakes has a reputation beyond repute KillinSnakes has a reputation beyond repute KillinSnakes has a reputation beyond repute KillinSnakes has a reputation beyond repute KillinSnakes has a reputation beyond repute KillinSnakes has a reputation beyond repute KillinSnakes has a reputation beyond repute KillinSnakes has a reputation beyond repute KillinSnakes has a reputation beyond repute KillinSnakes has a reputation beyond repute KillinSnakes has a reputation beyond repute KillinSnakes's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2007
    Location
    "apologist scum"
    Posts
    4,679
    Thanks
    665
    Thanked 274 Times in 114 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by Cael View Post
    Its only a contraction if you consider that a centralised state is the only form a Republic can have. I don't see any reason to believe this. It's true that many Anarchists do not want borders of any type, but by no means all. In the Spainish civil war some of the most patriotic fighters were Anarchists, and they certainly had no desire to see the end of Spain.
    We don't personally consider it a contradiction, as you suggest. rather, history has shown it to be a contradiction.

    The problem of anarchists being default patriots that did not want to break up Spain is precisely the problem. Had they the anarchist ministers in the bourgeois republican government perhaps issued statements to the effect that Morocco would gain independence under the Spanish Republic, that could have undercut Franco's primary source of troops before the German and Italian intervention.

    Quote Originally Posted by Cael View Post
    A Republic based on Community Councils is no contradiction at all. Indeed, Cuba has already done a lot of work towards this goal. You would still need a Federal System, similar to the one outlined in Éire Nua, and Dáil Éireann would then be an assembly of delegates rather than representatives. I believe that would be a great improvement.
    Rule by workers and/or commuity councils in a 32 county Irish Republic is already advocated by one party- the IRSP. IRSP Ard Fheiseanna have outlined this idea in the past.

    as for Eire Nua, we reject it because it would keep loyalism alive in the Da/il Ulaidh. Whereas we argue that protestants will have to break with loyalism in the Republic- not be rewarded for it.
    Subscribe to the IRSCNA Youtube Channel http://www.youtube.com/user/IRSCNA

    "Radical theory tends to grow unpleasantly narcissistic when deprived of a political outlet." -Terry Eagleton

  10. #10
    Banned Red Revolutionary is just really nice Red Revolutionary is just really nice Red Revolutionary is just really nice Red Revolutionary is just really nice Red Revolutionary is just really nice
    Join Date
    May 2007
    Location
    The Moral High Ground
    Posts
    4,298
    Thanks
    0
    Thanked 3 Times in 3 Posts
    Quote Originally Posted by KillinSnakes View Post
    We don't personally consider it a contradiction, as you suggest. rather, history has shown it to be a contradiction.

    The problem of anarchists being default patriots that did not want to break up Spain is precisely the problem. Had they the anarchist ministers in the bourgeois republican government perhaps issued statements to the effect that Morocco would gain independence under the Spanish Republic, that could have undercut Franco's primary source of troops before the German and Italian intervention.



    Rule by workers and/or commuity councils in a 32 county Irish Republic is already advocated by one party- the IRSP. IRSP Ard Fheiseanna have outlined this idea in the past.

    as for Eire Nua, we reject it because it would keep loyalism alive in the Da/il Ulaidh. Whereas we argue that protestants will have to break with loyalism in the Republic- not be rewarded for it.
    In one post.

+ Reply to Thread

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
The owners of this forum are not responsible for views of members nor or we liable for any repercussions as a result of user's posts.